Saturday , October 21 2017

Opinion: Why I’ve broken up with Chrome


If we have a good relationship you will be moved if I touch you.
If I’m gentle, you will respond in kind.
If I’m rough with you I expect you to be rough too.

What am I talking about?

It’s no secret that I’m a Google fan. I have a Google laptop, a Google tablet and a Google phone. I live happily in a Google ecosystem with Google apps that rarely let me down.

Gmail works well for me. So do Google’s Maps and their video service YouTube. Google Calendar keeps me from missing events. All in all I’m a happy little Googler. Google Chrome on my PC and my Chromebook serve me well.

But what should possibly be the crowning glory of our relationship has failed me too many times. Yes, I’m talking about Chrome for Android. I’ve been with her since I met her.

I like that she knows my needs, and usually serves up just what I’m after when I ask. She knows how to communicate with my other friends (my apps) and helps me to achieve my goals.

But lately, it’s like she’s stuck. I try to prod her gently, but she moves so slowly.

I won’t strain this metaphor any further: Chrome for Android is laggy. There I said it. It’s stuttery and not buttery. It sometimes won’t move at all.

We demand responsiveness from our gadgets like we do from our vehicles. If I press the accelerator pedal with my foot, I expect instant movement. If not I will call the service centre and get it looked at.

Stuttery and not buttery

So I’ve called it quits with Chrome for Android. For now. I put up with this for a while and probably would have continued to be patient in this relationship but… you guessed it, I met someone else. It was a chance encounter.

Her name is Dolphin. She’s so in tune with me. When I touch her the response is instant and she can really move! I’ve uninstalled Chrome for Android from my phone and tablet – Dolphin has taken her place. Maybe Chrome and I will get back together again one day.

If you’ve experienced the same, I suggest giving Dolphin a try. Firefox is pretty good too, but I prefer the tabs in Dolphin, because they’re much more like a desktop browser.

I believe Google needs to act quickly and decisively. If you have at least a dual core phone or tablet running Jelly Bean, you have the right to expect responsiveness. Project Butter is a reality right across the Google apps and system user experience of my Nexus phone and tablet. Google’s own browser should be no different.

We know you can do it, Google. Give us faithful fans something to be proud of. Then we geeks will continue to promote what we know and love. Because right now, we’re just a little bit embarrassed… I guess you are too?

[appaware-app pname=’mobi.mgeek.TunnyBrowser’ name=’Dolphin Browser’ qrcode=’true’ users=’0′]

Do you share Geoff’s feelings about Chrome for Android? Let us know in the comments!

 

Geoff Fieldew  

Join the Ausdroid Conversation

75 Comments on "Opinion: Why I’ve broken up with Chrome"

avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Ryan
Valued Guest
Ryan

Chrome for Android stalls out regularly on my Galaxy S II 🙁

tysoncsmith
Valued Guest
tysoncsmith

Great News,
There was an update to Chrome and it has become stable again on the Note 10.1
Anyone else had some success with the chrome update?

Member

Has the latest update for Chrome (which was released yesterday) has made the experience any better for you guys?

Member

Nope. Not yet.

StuartM
Valued Guest
StuartM

Stock browser all the way. Buttery smooth and you can browse full screen if you turn on Quick Controls in Labs.

Member

I have been checking out the stock browser again on the GS3 & GNex. The GS3 browser is the fastest I’ve used on a phone. It gets about 1100 in the JavaScript Sunspider test. It’s nice and smooth.

My concern is that I will have trouble getting it on the Nexus 4 and Nexus 7. The major turnoff though is the time consuming method that is switching between windows. I like to see what’s open at a glance and open another in one step.

NinjaBoy
Valued Guest

I can say that Chrome is extremly horrid on Android, both on my Galaxy Nexus and my Nexus 10. Ironically the native browser in the Galaxy Nexus works better.

On that note — — Chrome on MAC OSx is horrid too. Using up anywhere up to 1GB of memory, eventually becomes unusable and laggy. Thoughts?

Taufiq Khan
Valued Guest

Yeah… love/hate relationship with Chrome. I can’t peel myself away from the amazing tab syncing between devices, but the lag is a bother

Member

Yep. My exact frustration too.

Member

So, Chrome has an update. Maybe some reminiscing in the air?

Roe
Valued Guest

Boat browser easily the best and reliable

HTC
Valued Guest

Chrome browser lag.

It is caused by a functionality in
Chrome Android called FlingCancel that is triggered at the start of a
touch event, if the acknowledgement is not received it gets moved from
the compositor thread to the webkit thread, but the browser is still
waiting for the FlingCancel acknowledgement before it sends the touch
response.” forum member Turbotab commented, ”This explains why some reviews thought that the very powerful Nexus 4 & 10 were laggy when web browsing”.
Surprisingly, Google marked the report
as a ‘Pri-2′ issue instead of ‘Pri-1′ which is quite ironic given that
user experience should be a top priority

Milty Mc
Valued Guest

Yes chrome is very laggy, but when i tried out the other options they were just as bad. So ive stuck with chrome. I still hate browsing the net on android.

Julian Williams
Valued Guest
Julian Williams

What I don’t understand is the love triangle that is Android + Android Stock Browser + Google Chrome. It has always been like Chrome is the third wheel in the relationship.

If Google wanted us to use Chrome all through our lives, (on the Desktop, on the phone, on tablet), then why did they not do away with the Stock Browser and make Google Chrome the default? Seems like the Android OS developers and Chrome developers couldn’t agree on that part of the Google ecosystem…

Member

Chrome is now the Heir Apparent I believe. I guess it’s a bit like Ramses and Moses 😉

Thomas Bridgewater
Valued Guest
Thomas Bridgewater

The thing is, I love the interface of chrome. I love the integration. I use the open tabs feature loads. If it weren’t for this, I would have moved long ago. google really do need to fix this.

BBbbbbbbBbb
Valued Guest
BBbbbbbbBbb

I’m the same as you I’ve always loved everything google but I have TOTALLY removed Chrome from my SGS2 so I’ll not be tempted to keep coming back to it. I’ve used dolphin for a few months now and so far so good. I’m AMAZED that with the billions that Google has they can’t get the most important thing right.

Member

You’re right. The browser is the one app that must be cream of the crop.

Baked420
Valued Guest
Baked420

I’ve been using Chrome on the PC since it came out and on my Galaxy S3….and I’m really not sure what is wrong with your phone as its smooth and super fast on mine.

Rob Reid
Valued Guest
Rob Reid

Before you all run off and install Dolphin, consider what kind of developers allow this kind of “privacy blunder”: http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2011/10/major-privacy-flaw-found-in-dolphin-hd-browser-for-android/

Christopher Theofilaktos
Valued Guest
Christopher Theofilaktos

It’s horrendous, completely unusable. There’s absolutely no reason a quad core phone with 1gb of ram (S3) should lag when browsing the web. Firefox has been working great but I might check out Dolphin once again, I hope Google fix this soon because I really love Google and Chrome.

Member

That is the point. We don’t hate Google or Chrome. We want them to make a great product. Also, we want them to know if their product isn’t great.

homebrandcola
Valued Guest
I’ve gone through the same thing. Chrome came out, with a beta tag, and it was new, shiny, sucked battery like no one’s business, but it rendered pages really well, and was, well rather shiny. After a few updates it got better, and more stable. Then Jelly Bean came out, and all was well with the world. But with the last few updates to Chrome it has got more and more bloated, and s l o w e r. Then the bugs set in, opening a link to my bank caused Chrome to completely lock up on my SGS2. This… Read more »
Sam Ng
Valued Guest
Sam Ng

I use naked browser now.

Very speedy

Harpersneil
Valued Guest
Harpersneil

Amazing that I’m reading this today. Only last week I replaced Chrome with Dolphin and (I hope she’s not reading this), I’ve never been happier.

We waited an eternity for Chome, but sadly it’s been nothing but disappointing so far. I think I read on Ausdroid that Chrome and Android are in fact 2 totally seperate dept’s in Google. Perhaps that’s still an issue?

Great article!

Paul FIeldew
Valued Guest
Paul FIeldew

Hey Bro, I had a read and I did watch the video chrome vs dolphin. I agree that Chrome is not loading well, not buttery and confusing by operation at times. I am trying Dolphin on my Nexus 10, going well, not completely sold either, takes a little while to initially load a page but overall does seem to run better than chrome. Not up for discussion here but still can’t go past chrome on win 7, love it. Also waiting for chrome to hopefully come back strong on Android.

gutenmuach
Valued Guest
gutenmuach

Google, can you also please add the ability to zoom out/in in gmail please……

Mitchell Smith
Valued Guest
Mitchell Smith

They have

Altechi
Valued Guest
Altechi

I left chrome mainly because bookmarks disappear when sync is not on. Which is really annoying. I prefer using stock, which in the s3 is pretty good and snappy. Doesn’t drain the battery as much as well

Matt Stow
Valued Guest

I still solely use the Android browser because it implements reflowing text after zooming. No other browser does and I can’t live without it. If they kill Browser before implementing this in Chrome I won’t be pleased. You can vote for my issue if you like: http://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=136329

Sam Ng
Valued Guest
Sam Ng

Naked browser has it. It’s based on the aosp browser

glennv17
Valued Guest
glennv17
I used to hate Chrome on my Acer A500, but I persisted with it for bookmarks and desktop sync. I’ve used it since it came out on my Galaxy Nexus and it’s been fine to be honest. I don’t do heavy browsing on my phone usually anyway. I love it a lot more on my Nexus 7 than I did on my A500, and even though I know it could be better, I find it just fine for the browsing that I do. I haven’t used the AOSP browser for a long, long time. I know I can use things… Read more »
van casipong
Valued Guest

There are features I like on Chrome, like Chrome to Phone, and to be able to Sync with other devices. But it’s sad that Flash, and Pop-up Browser are not supported, and it also uses a high amount of memory. With this, I am still using both Chrome and the AOSP Browser.

Justin Harvey
Valued Guest
Justin Harvey

Not sure if you saw this post from Google chrome plus account

https://plus.google.com/100585555255542998765/posts/e9HVLDwfjLr

not that i really think it will change a whole lot but we can live in hope

pdffs
Valued Guest
pdffs

Quick Menu is a necessity for me – AOSP browser for life.

NOZ
Valued Guest
I understand what everyone was saying. I have an S3. The quadcore 1gb variety. Ive always had chrome installed. As well as firefox and opera. I prefer different browsers for different reasons I suppose. It wasnt until recently that I actually began to use chrome more regularly. For various reasons…and I cant pinpoint it exactly…ive noticed huge improvements. Initially on the s3 it was laggy as can be. And didnt use it but checked back everytime there was an update and/or I updated the rom in my phone. So its hard to tell if its the leaked rom im currently… Read more »
Mr Pendulum
Valued Guest

I had problems initially. But they disappeared for me a couple of months ago with an update. Either that or I’m experiencing stockholm syndrome with it.

ozgreg
Valued Guest
ozgreg

Ahhh how soon we forget, it was only 12 months ago that Dolphin was caught sending URL’s back to a remote server in plain text.. Dare we trust them again?

Member

That rings a bell, hmm. I’m giving them a chance to prove they’ve learnt their lesson then I suppose.

tysoncsmith
Valued Guest
tysoncsmith

Agreed, same here. Chrome is fine on my G-Nex 4.2 but on my galaxy note 10.1 it just freezes and becomes unusable until it crashes. Will give dolphin a go but the stock browser seems to be going strong. Thanks for the article

Member

You’re welcome 🙂

Member
Google Chrome on Android is rubbish. I am a Googler too. I use it everywhere possible and find the connectivity between products typically great. But I have sideloaded the old Android browser on all my devices. One issue of the many issues I had with Chrome on Android was if I wanted to use the desktop version of Google docs in the browser (the drive version functionality is not that comprehensive yet) and switch from my personal Google account to my works business Google account, no can do. I have to remove my personal account and add my business account.… Read more »
Member

Yep, you’re right where I am.

Pete
Valued Guest
Pete

Chrome for Android is good on the Nexus 4, slightly laggy on the Nexus 7, and absolutely unusable on the Nexus S. Pretty bad on the ‘wingray’ Xoom too.

Member

Possibly due to the brute force of S4Pro + 2GB RAM in Nexus 4?

Daniel Tyson
Ausdroid Manager

I do find that occasionally opening a link from somewhere like Twitter etc, Chrome just sits there on a blank page and you have to re-tap the link

Member

Shall we call this the Chrome white screen of death?

Jason Murray
Valued Guest

I’m also thinking brute force explains Nexus 4 performance.

Member

You have a Nexus 4 and Nexus 7, yes? How is it on your Nexus 7?

Jason Murray
Valued Guest

Nexus 7 is performing badly in general. Not entirely sure why TBH – need to get 4.2 on there.

Member

Maybe time for a reset.

pcoussa
Valued Guest
pcoussa

Got say Geoff that I went through exactly the same thing. I too moved away from Chrome and FF has replaced my daily driver for a browser!!!

Scott
Valued Guest

i too am using Firefox on my lg nexus 4… it has decent sync to desktop too. i still use chrome on my tablet as i can easily open something i had open on chrome on pc

Member

I’ve had Firefox on the Nexus 7 for handling flash content for a while. I’ll probably keep it there.

Member

Happy Dolphin user here 🙂 I’d be happier if it synced Chrome bookmarks, but theres an app for that…

Member

There’s an app? Link me pls!

Member

I’ll try the cloud from the other response, Dolphin dropped their sync and I’m surprised if they implemented another solution they didn’t say so… Anyway I’m using the heavy version of “https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.h.chromemarks.lite”.

Member

Thx 🙂

Arek
Valued Guest
Arek

There is actually an option, swipe screen to the right and in the bookmark strip on the top left there is a cloud symbol, select other accounts and login with google…

Member

I can’t find the “cloud” option… Is this documented somewhere?

JeniSkunk
Valued Guest
JeniSkunk

From the left edge of the Dolphin screen, swipe right.
The cloud sync symbol is in the top left corner of the Bookmarks.
Tap it, then choose what account to Connect with. Facebook, Google, or Dolphin.

Member

Pressing the cloud syncs (something) for me and even long pressing doesn’t do anything (no add other accounts options).

I’m sticking with cmarks as the only thing that seems to sync from chrome is the history (not even sure about that), no bookmarks sync. The CMARKS bookmark menu however seems fully populated, so thats handy.

Member

Cheers for that 🙂

Chris (Deputy Editor)
Valued Guest

Excellent suggestion .. I may even investigate this, even though I haven’t found Chrome on Android too bad – works alright for me on N7 and RAZR M.

Bakaouji
Valued Guest
Bakaouji

Agreed. Chrome definitely has some lag issues, on my Nexus 7 as well as Galaxy Nexus. And I hear it’s even worse on non-nexus devices with force closes and whatnot.

Sadly, I prefer the UI of Chrome, so I’m still using it.

What device are you using btw?

Member

Same as you. I’m all Nexus.

aryonoco
Valued Guest
aryonoco

Yeah… but Dolphin has its own problems.

Try the new Firefox 18 (that’s just hit beta). I’m finding it amazing.

Greg
Valued Guest
Greg

Love firefox – and its a must for integrating with all of my FF desktops. Only complaint is the startup-loading time when you start fresh or get kicked out of memory.

Member

I’ll give it a shot. Responsiveness is what I’m after and so far Dolphin hasn’t disappointed me.

Scott
Valued Guest

i use firefox on my nexus 4 Geoff. really nice. smooth.

wpDiscuz

Check Also

Huawei Mate 10 Pro up with the best in benchmark tests, including a 97 on DxOMark

Although benchmarks do not always extrapolate into real-world performance but more often than not are …