Saturday , October 21 2017

What Phone Should I Buy My Mum?


As tech enthusiasts we, and most likely many of you, are often asked what phone should I buy my mother/father/grandmother/daughter/son etc. Unfortunately, or fortunately, depending on how you view it, the coverage of low end phones is often far too stark. This is what people want to buy their relative that is a bit of a tech nuffie and does NOT need a Pixel etc. Or they want a simple phone for their young daughter or son that is not going to break the bank. We have decided to set that mark at a hard limit of AU$400 and give you a list and details of what we think are the best available phones in that price range.

The phones that caught our eye in that price range are:

  • Oppo F1s
  • Sony Xperia XA
  • Huawei GR3
  • Samsung J3
  • Samsung J5
  • HTC Desire 628
  • LG X Power

Let’s start in reverse order — the ones I wouldn’t touch with a barge pole to those that I highly recommend.

The Samsungs

The very limited time we had with both of these devices was far too short to recommend it to anyone. With Samsung unable to provide us with review phones for these we are unable to give more than a passing comment from what we learnt from using them instore.


The phones come with the usual Samsung “value-added software” (or bloatware if you wish) and they did not feel very snappy at all. If TouchWiz/Samsung Experience slows down even their high end flagships over time I have very little confidence with it producing a decent experience on a low end phone such as these. The J5 retails for around AU$399 while the J3 can be purchased from Telstra on their prepaid plans for AU$299. There are far better phones out there for that price range.

HTC Desire 628

As for the Samsung’s we did not get much of a chance to use these except for instore. The 5 inch display on these is a 720p LCD display which seems fairly washed out and not of great quality. The phone itself is a good looking phone that retails for AU$249 at JB Hifi.

The OS flows fairly well and is relatively snappy so it is not one that I would rule out but having used others for longer I am much more confident recommending those others for similar prices. With 2GB of RAM and 16GB of storage which can be expanded with microSD it has acceptable specs for a low-mid range phone. In saying that this fits 3rd from the end in my list of phones I would recommend out of those listed above.

Huawei GR3

We cannot do a list of low-mid range phones and not include Huawei. The very impressive Huawei Nova Plus unfortunately sits just outside of the price range at a RRP of AU$499 (it is $486 at Harvey Norman at the moment so you may be able to bargain a bit of that). If the budget extends to that price we highly recommend it with a review set to be published any day now. The Huawei phone that is readily available within this price range is the Huawei GR3.

Huawei, in 2016, excels in the design stakes with most of their phones including an all-metal body. The GR3 is no exception and feels very solid in the hand. The GR3 has just been released in a bundle with a fitness tracker for AU$279 which we have seen at Target. The 5 inch display is a 720p IPS LCD display that looks decent, for a low end phone. The specs themselves are very similar to the HTC and it behaves similarly, albeit with the woeful EMUI 3.1 ontop of Android 5.1.1. Where the Huawei excels is its build quality. It came in fourth in my list of phones above that we considered. I find it hard to recommend a phone running Lollipop with a hideous skin on top no matter how good the build quality is.

Sony Xperia XA

The last three phones are all phones I would consider recommending to friends or relatives who want a quality phone without breaking the bank.

Sony were good enough to supply us with an Xperia XA to test out as part of this article and considering our previous experience with some Sony devices we were more than sceptical. I was surprised. It was a decent little phone. It follows the design language of the rest of their devices in its shape. The display is a very nice 5 inch, 720P IPS LCD display that looks pretty good, even next to my Pixel XL. Colours were vibrant and sharp.

Running on top of Android 6.0 was a half decent skin by Sony. Very minimal and thus seemed to be relatively quick, not Pixel quick of course but definitely no slouch, especially for a sub AU$200 phone. I read somewhere that Sony included a heap of bloatware on the device. I noticed no such thing. There is of course the usual Sony apps where they are continually persistent with trying to lock you into their walled garden with apps etc from them (Playstation, Xperia Lounge, Xperia Tips), AVG Protection which is nothing but a drain on the battery (not required, hurts more than helps), and Facebook (possibly the worst coded app known to Android and will kill any battery given half the chance — use a different app if you must have Facebook). I wouldn’t consider these bloatware to any great extent and if wanted you could always disable them- which I did. With an upgrade to Android 7.0 in the works software is not something that lets this phone down.

The 13MP rear camera was a decent camera, taking some good snaps (see below) and the front facing camera, at 8MP, took some decent selfies (which is the most important factor right?).

It has the usual specs expected from a phone in this range — 16GB storage, 2GB RAM, microSD slot, octa-core processor, all the Wi-Fis and Bluetooth 4.1. The battery life was decent, not great but lasted a day fairly easily. This is where this phone fell a bit behind the last two phones but is entirely acceptable in my opinion. You can pick this one up prepaid from Vodafone for AU$199 or outright from JB Hifi for AU$299.

Would I recommend this phone to a relative? In a nutshell, yes. It is the closest experience to stock Android out of my final 3 which runs well and has a decent camera. With software upgrades on the horizon its software experience excels. It was not far behind the LG X Power at all and I suspect many would actually prefer this one over the LG. It is a much nicer looking phone, especially the white one we received.

LG X Power

It was close between the LG X Power and the Oppo F1s but in the end the Oppo won out as my number one recommendation due to its supreme build quality as opposed to the extremely plasticky feel of the LG. The LG X Power’s battery life set it apart from the Sony Xperia XA. The software experience matters little to those that this phone and this market category is aimed at.

When I reviewed the LG X Power a couple of months ago I concluded that yes I would recommend it to a certain subset of people. Those who want a phone with a helluva battery life. It worked intermittently with Android Auto and felt not that great in the hand but it worked as designed considering its low end specs.

The camera was good but not great, once again, but for a sub-$300 phone we shouldn’t expect DSLR quality images. As per most of the phones listed above there is 2GB of RAM and 16GB of storage with capability to expand that with microSD. The display is slightly bigger than those above at 5.3 inches and is protected with Gorilla Glass 3. The display colours did not “pop” but were acceptable- especially for someone like my Mum who knows no better.

The software is a let down, as it is for many companies trying to set themselves apart from the pack of Android manufacturers. I dislike their “skin” with a passion and think it is a blight on the Android landscape. Aside from that the phone is a decent piece of kit. Most people who this phone is targeted at would not care about the software and its divergence from the Material Design guidelines.

The battery life, with me using the hell out of it, was over two days! Impressive to say the least. Add in the fast charging that all manufacturers seem to have now and it is good for those who often forget to charge their device every night (eg. my Mum). At AU$299 from JB Hifi it comes in second in my list and is good buy for anyone out there who don’t mind the LG skin.

Oppo F1s

This is a phone that I have not used for more than a day or so but left a lasting impression on me. The build quality is similar to Huawei — an all metal body that feels premium in the hand.

With a bump in specs over the other phones mentioned above it performs extremely well. There is 3GB of RAM and 32GB of storage which can be further increased with a microSD card. The processor is a Mediatek Octa-core processor. The 720p LCD display is also bigger at 5.5 inches and had possibly the best looking display of all other the phones in this article.

Hardware aside the phone is only running Android 5.1 which is extremely disappointing, especially when their “skin”, ColorOS, is every bit as hideous as EMUI and LG’s UX5.0. Oppo have said that an update to 6.0 is in the works but they need to add their “skin” to it which is what takes all the time. Makes you wonder why they do it — it certainly does not enhance the phone in any way.

The performance of the phone was far better than what you would expect of a AU$318 phone. As Phil said in his review “For the target market, the performance of the F1s is going to be more than satisfactory – they’ll think this thing is an absolute beast”. Same for the software. Mentioned to a friend who bought one about the software but she was more than happy with it — mind you she was coming from a SGS4 with TouchWiz (enough said).

The battery life was not over two days like the LG X Power but was easily over a day with heavy use. Oppo’s VOOC charging is also included and is one of the better and faster fast charging protocols out there.

Currently on sale at JB Hifi for AU$318 it is hard to go past this bargain. It is a beast of a phone for that price. It is doesn’t miss a beat performance-wise and is a great size for media consumption for the YouTube hungry teenager and easy to use with long battery life for the older tech nuffie in your life. For this reason it is my current go to recommendation for a sub-$400 phone for your Mum/Dad/Grandparent/Daughter/Son.

 LG X PowerSony Xperia XAOppo F1S
Release dateFebruary 2016 August 2016
Screen size5.3-inch5.0-inch5.5-inch
Screen technologyIPS LCDIPS LCDLCD
Resolution1,280 x 7201,280 x 7201,280 x 720
PPI277294267
Rear camera13MP13MP13MP
Front camera5MP8MP16MP
ChipsetMediaTek MT6735MediaTek helio P10MediaTek MT6750
Core config1.3GHz x 42.0 GHz x 88 x 1.5 GHz
Ram2GB2GB3GB
Storage16GB16GB32GB
MicroSDYes, Up to 2TBYes, up to 200GBYes, up to 128GB
Battery4,100 mAh2,300 mAh3,075 mAh
Battery removable
ConnectorMicroUSBMicroUSBMicroUSB
Headphone PortYesYesYes
Headphone LocationBottomBottom
Speaker ConfigurationBack
Android OSAndroid 6.0.1Android 6.0.1Android 5.1
Vendor skinLG UXXperia UIColorOS 3.0
Dimensions148.9x74.9x7.9mm143.6 x 66.8 x 7.9 mm154.5 x 76 x 7.4 mm
Weight139g137g160g
ColoursBlack
  • White
  • Graphite Black
  • Lime Gold
  • Rose Gold
  • Gold
  • Rose Gold
  • Gray

In the end, while the Oppo F1s ran away with the title of best phone for my Mum (but can obviously be applied to many of the aforementioned people – including as a back to school option for the kids), any of the last three are good choices that your friend/relative will not be unhappy with if you recommend them. The Sony Xperia XA was a great looking device with good software and half decent battery life. The LG X Power was a not so good looking device that ran well with amazing battery life. The Oppo F1s was an amazing looking device with specs that were better than any other device with really good battery life. All three had good camera that more than pass the test for a cheap phone.

 

Scott Plowman   Associate Editor

Scott is our modding guru - he has his finger on the pulse of all things ‘moddable’, pointing us towards all the cutting edge mods hacks that are available. When he’s not gymming it up, or scanning the heck out of Nexus devices, you'll find him on the Ausdroid Podcast.

Outside of Ausdroid, Scott's a health care professional and lecturer at a well known Victorian university.

Join the Ausdroid Conversation

23 Comments on "What Phone Should I Buy My Mum?"

avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Erland Howden
Valued Guest
Wait, wait, how did the Moto G4 Plus not make it on to this list? $399 for the 16GB version from Motorola but the 32GB/3GB RAM version can be had for under $400 online. This was my choice for a family member most recently. Seems at least on par with the Oppo and a hands-down winner over the rest. The other option I was surprised to not see on this list is the Nextbit Robin – I know it’s getting longer in the tooth now but forgetting about the whole cloud storage thing the specs and near-stock software alone make… Read more »
Greg
Valued Guest
Greg

Yep $350 for G4 plus at good guys – bought today!

Member

Can you even buy the Nextbit Robin in Australia?

Member
Matt

Currently ~ $150 USD delivered to Aus on Amazon.

Rick
Valued Guest
Rick

No Moto G4 Plus?

KJ
Valued Guest

iPhone 5s on prepaid, $369, running latest iOS and will probably keep on getting updates longer than these phones. Excellent ecosystem, hardware and build quality. Can’t go wrong.

montalbert_scott
Valued Guest
montalbert_scott

decent hardware. terrible software.

SachmoJoe
Valued Guest
SachmoJoe

Look, I’m am android guy through and through, but calling iOS terrible software when you’re recommending Oppo and Huawei phones? Hmmm

Member
Matt

My mum is rocking her original moto g and she still loves it. I just got her a new flip cover a few weeks ago (getting hard to find).

Member

The original Moto G, the one with a 4.5″ screen?

Either way the Moto G series has great Cyanogenmod support, think theyre all on Nougat.

David Anderton
Valued Guest
David Anderton

Moto G4 or G4 plus

Andrew
Valued Guest
Andrew

Great article. My mum is so on the HTC One M7 and is due for a new phone. This article has come in handy. The Oppo F1 sounds solid. I’ll check it out.

Annoying Old Fart
Valued Guest
Annoying Old Fart

An ugly read. FYI, “it’s” = “it is”.

Malcolm Bowes
Valued Guest
Malcolm Bowes

I recently purchased a Huawei GR5 for my mother-in-law. She loves it and to be honest I’m very impressed with what it offers for AU$298 (currently on sale at JB). As a bonus, it is supplied with a gel case and a factory fitted screen protector.

montalbert_scott
Valued Guest
montalbert_scott

Huawei and oppo are really kicking goals this year and their sales figures show that. The rest of the market is stagnating but not them

freshj1ve
Valued Guest
freshj1ve

I got my mum a F1s too! 😊

Member

Moto G4 Play
The newly released ZTE Blade A610
Xperia XA

Rick
Valued Guest
Rick

G4 Plus can be had under $400 and is a much better phone than the G4 Play (which is a rebadged G3).

Member

True, I just don’t like phones bigger than 5″ screen 😛

SachmoJoe
Valued Guest
SachmoJoe

Could always jump online and get a grey import Nexus 5X – I still think that phone is excellent value for money at around $300.

montalbert_scott
Valued Guest
montalbert_scott

your experience is obviously different to all the 5x we have tested. They were all dogs

SachmoJoe
Valued Guest
SachmoJoe

It’s been pretty well documented that the software build on the 5X has some pretty serious performance issues on release, but updates have corrected this and as of now this thing runs like a dream. Obviously the slow camera is still an issue but in the price bracket this is a great phone.

Member

Really? Seems like a great phone

wpDiscuz

Check Also

Huawei Mate 10 Pro up with the best in benchmark tests, including a 97 on DxOMark

Although benchmarks do not always extrapolate into real-world performance but more often than not are …